Christmas Would You Rather
Fifty holiday dilemmas, from silly to impossible. Draw a card, read it out, everyone picks a side and defends it. No repeats until the deck runs out; the full list is below for printing.
50 cards left
How to play
- 1Draw a card and read the question out loud.
- 2Everyone picks one answer at once: raise a hand, point left or right, or shout it.
- 3The smallest side has ten seconds to explain itself. Anyone convinced can switch.
- 4Draw the next card. Keep score if you like: a point for each time you were in the majority.
For kids, for adults, for work
Every question here works for all ages, so you can mix a family table with no editing. With kids, read the card and let them answer first, before the adults sway them. At work, it's a two-minute icebreaker before a meeting or a round between courses at the office party, and nobody has to share anything personal.
Turn it into a game with points
Split into two teams. Before each card, a team guesses which answer the other team will pick. A right guess scores a point; first to ten wins. It's surprisingly hard to predict your coworkers.
All 50 questions
- Would you rather wrap every gift in the house or untangle every string of lights?
- Would you rather eat only Christmas cookies for a week or only turkey for a week?
- Would you rather get one huge gift or twenty tiny ones?
- Would you rather have a real tree that drops needles or a fake one that never smells of pine?
- Would you rather spend Christmas on a beach or in a snowed-in cabin?
- Would you rather sing a carol solo at the office party or give a five-minute speech?
- Would you rather know all your gifts in advance or never be able to guess one?
- Would you rather wear an ugly Christmas sweater every day in December or never wear one again?
- Would you rather be one of Santa's elves or one of his reindeer?
- Would you rather have Christmas music playing everywhere or nowhere at all?
- Would you rather build a snowman or have a snowball fight?
- Would you rather open your gifts on Christmas Eve or on Christmas morning?
- Would you rather drink only hot chocolate or only eggnog all season?
- Would you rather host Christmas dinner for twenty or travel to three family dinners?
- Would you rather get socks every year or a surprise that might be awful?
- Would you rather have a white Christmas or a warm, sunny one?
- Would you rather decorate the tree or put up the outside lights?
- Would you rather watch the same Christmas movie ten times or ten Christmas movies you've never heard of?
- Would you rather ride in Santa's sleigh or visit the North Pole workshop?
- Would you rather give the best gift at the exchange or receive it?
- Would you rather lose your voice before carols or lose your appetite before dinner?
- Would you rather have a gingerbread house you can live in or a sleigh you can fly?
- Would you rather find coal in your stocking or an empty stocking?
- Would you rather shop for gifts on December 1 or on December 24?
- Would you rather be Secret Santa for your boss or for your ex?
- Would you rather celebrate Christmas every month or only once every two years?
- Would you rather have Christmas lights that never turn off or a tree that never stops shedding?
- Would you rather skate on a frozen lake or sled down a huge hill?
- Would you rather be stuck in an elevator with a carol singer or a mall Santa?
- Would you rather get a handmade gift or one from your wishlist?
- Would you rather have reindeer as pets or penguins as neighbours?
- Would you rather eat the whole Christmas pudding or never taste it again?
- Would you rather wake up on Christmas morning at 5 a.m. or sleep through the gifts?
- Would you rather write fifty Christmas cards or wrap fifty gifts?
- Would you rather spend Christmas with Santa or with the Grinch?
- Would you rather have a talking snowman or a dancing Christmas tree?
- Would you rather lose the TV remote or the tape for the whole holiday?
- Would you rather get everything on your wishlist or one thing nobody knew you wanted?
- Would you rather have mistletoe follow you around or a jingle bell on every step?
- Would you rather be an elf who makes toys or an elf who tests them?
- Would you rather give up Christmas cookies or Christmas music?
- Would you rather play White Elephant with strangers or Secret Santa with family?
- Would you rather have a fireplace with no fire or a fire with no fireplace?
- Would you rather lead the carols or bake for the whole street?
- Would you rather have Christmas in July or Halloween in December?
- Would you rather find the perfect gift in five minutes or enjoy five hours of shopping?
- Would you rather be snowed in with your family or stuck at the airport alone?
- Would you rather have a stocking that refills every morning or a tree that grows new gifts?
- Would you rather start decorating in October or the week before Christmas?
- Would you rather keep the decorations up until February or take them down on Boxing Day?
Playing a gift game? Draw the names first
Secret Santa, White Elephant and gift exchanges for any group: one invite link, a fair one-click draw, wishlists in the same place. Free, no sign-up.
Would You Rather questions
Do the cards repeat?
No. The deck is shuffled when you start and each question comes up once. When it runs out, shuffle again.
Are the questions OK for kids?
Yes. All fifty are family-friendly; the hardest choice is between cookies and turkey.
Can I print the questions?
The full list is on this page; print it from your browser or copy the ones you like.